OCALA, FL (352Today.com) – After hours of public comment that went until almost 8 p.m. on Tuesday, Marion County commissioners voted 3-2 to approve a special use permit for a private, members-only outdoor shooting range on a former borrow pit next to Indian Lake State Forest.

On November 17, 2026, the Board of County Commissioners granted the permit for the roughly 10-acre site at 3805 NE 77th Street, about a half-mile north of State Road 326, after nearly five hours of testimony. The range will sit inside a pit excavated 20 to 30 feet below surrounding grade, with a 200-yard rifle range, a pistol range and training bays oriented south into additional berms. The closest equestrian trail in Indian Lake State Forest is roughly one-third of a mile from the easternmost shooting lane. Because the property is already zoned agricultural, the owner and guests could shoot there by right under state law; the special use permit allows a members-only club while imposing conditions on hours, lead control, groundwater monitoring, road improvements and a three-year initial term.

Before public comment, applicant engineer David Tillman told the board the recessed pit and berms would keep noise and projectiles on site. He played sound-meter recordings and said peak readings reached only about 51-53 decibels at the nearest residence and trail, which are comparable, he said, to a refrigerator or moderate rainfall and quieter than traffic or footsteps. Tillman argued that approving the permit would actually add enforceable limits that do not exist for unrestricted private use of the property.

Public comment ran for more than two hours and centered on horses, groundwater and the shift from private to commercial use.

Bernard Little, board president of Horse Farms Forever, spoke against the proposal and stressed the conflict with the county’s equestrian identity and the popular trails in Indian Lake State Forest. He argued that sudden gunfire next to a heavily used state forest would change the character of the trails and create safety risks for riders and horses that no set of conditions could fully eliminate. Little urged the board to protect the area’s rural and recreational character rather than allow a commercial range so close to the forest.

Busy Shires, conservation director for Horse Farms Forever, focused on the site’s location inside the Primary Springs Protection Zone. She told commissioners that outdoor ranges are normally allowed by right only in heavy industrial or heavy business zones, uses that are restricted in the springs zone without rigorous proof that groundwater will not be harmed. “Our springs and our groundwater are irreplaceable natural resources. Please protect them,” she said, warning that lead and other contaminants from the range could threaten the aquifer even with monitoring wells and catchment systems.

Kendall Tucker, co-owner of Ocala-based Intact Security, supported the request and said his firm’s more than 50 armed officers struggle to find safe, controlled places to train locally. He called the unregulated Ocala National Forest range unsafe and argued that a members-only facility with berms and rules would be a better option. Tucker added that he would have no hesitation about his wife and 7-year-old daughter riding horses near the site.

Randal Alvord, who had recently run for the District 4 commission seat, spoke during public comment and raised concerns about compatibility with surrounding rural and agricultural uses. He questioned whether the narrow access roads and the site’s proximity to the state forest and nearby properties made the location appropriate for a commercial-style range. Alvord told the board the conditions might look good on paper but could be difficult to enforce once the range was operating.

Tim Kirby, a retired commercial airline pilot and former federal flight deck officer, supported the project and said the recessed pit strikes a good balance. He described the site as “close enough for easy accessibility, yet isolated enough to ensure a safe environment.” Kirby noted that Jumbolair Aviation Estates is less than two miles away and generates far louder aircraft noise than the projected gunfire.

Patrick Conway spoke in opposition and focused on the potential impact on nearby residents and the quiet character of the area. He told commissioners that repeated gunfire, even if measured at relatively low decibels, would still alter the experience of living and recreating near the forest. Conway argued that the board should not approve a use that neighbors had not expected when they bought or built in the area.

Alex Arredondo spoke in support of the proposed members-only shooting range, saying he has known the applicant for about six years through the family’s business and local shooting competitions. Arredondo said he has personally watched the applicant work as a range officer and that he “takes firearm safety very seriously.” He told commissioners a controlled private range would be “a great addition to our community” because it would give members a place to practice, train, and improve their skills. “The more people that know about handling firearm safety, the better off everyone is,” Arredondo said. He added that with very few homes nearby and proper safety measures in place, he believes the location is reasonable.

Wayne Hunter also addressed the board and raised safety and traffic concerns tied to the narrow private access easement. He questioned whether the road improvements required by the permit would be enough to handle additional traffic and whether the county could realistically monitor compliance with the operating rules. Hunter said the risk to horses, riders and nearby property owners outweighed the benefits of adding another range.

Former Commissioner Kathy Bryant, who had left office only hours earlier, closed the public comment period. “This morning at 8:59 a.m., I concluded 16 years of service as a Marion County commissioner,” she said. “This evening, I find myself on the other side of the dais, and trust me, this is the last place I wanted to be this evening.” Bryant stressed that she was “150%” behind the Second Amendment but opposed the location. “My opposition is not to firearms or shooting ranges. It is to the proposed location and its potential impacts on surrounding properties.” She described her daughter and son-in-law’s nearby farm, said six years of work could be affected by repetitive gunfire, and warned that “imposing conditions on a special use permit is one thing. Monitoring and enforcing those conditions is quite another.” She called the concept solid but “just in the wrong location.”

After the comments, commissioners debated operating hours, the applicant’s self-conducted sound tests and the difference between private and commercial use. Commissioner Craig Curry, an avid hunter, said, “When you monetize it, this is the big difference to me…when you monetize it, you are guaranteeing you’re ramping this up to a commercial venture.” He questioned the noise data and opposed midnight shooting. Commissioner Stone joined him in dissent. The majority accepted staff’s recommendation with added conditions, including a three-year initial term, stronger lead-control measures, groundwater monitoring and road improvements.

Commissioners said the recessed site, distance to the trails and the new restrictions were sufficient to approve the permit while allowing a future review of real-world impacts on horses and neighbors.